<$BlogRSDUrl$>

Wednesday, June 28, 2006




EMAIL FROM LEE PENN

More Weird Liturgy?
"Our Lady" Rite Author Inspired By Labyrinth Walk

Commentary Report By Lee Penn
The Christian Challenge
June, 2006

For those wondering what inspired the Episcopal Church's newly-elected, female presiding bishop to refer to "Mother Jesus"
during the General Convention, the answer might be found on the "Office of Women's Ministries" (OWM) page on the official
national church website.

Indeed, this is not the first time that the OWM has gotten into liturgical mischief.

The phrase used by Bishop Katharine Jefferts Schori appears in a "Eucharist Using Female Nouns and Pronouns" on the OWM's section of the Episcopal Church (TEC)-sponsored website. The rite is accompanied by "Morning Prayers to the Lady" - and this does not mean our Lord's mother. Both services offer worship to "Our Lady" and to the "Holy Mother," and end with the salutation "Blessed be" - a common statement of farewell among Wiccans.

The author of the services, Sandra Thomas Fox, wrote them in 2001, five years after she had a feminist epiphany during her
first walk in a labyrinth - a spiritual exercise that actually has New Age roots - at the National Cathedral. There, she became
sensitized to "the misogyny in the liturgy."

The webpage that leads to the two feminist liturgies has an all-capitalized disclaimer for each: "NOT AN OFFICIAL LITURGY -
FOR USE IN DISCUSSION." Nevertheless, the pages from which each of the services can be downloaded invite readers to use them as
well in "gathering communities of worship." Therefore, these services can be used anywhere.

The feminist "Eucharist" invokes God thus: "Blessed be the Lady who births, redeems and sanctifies us."

The threefold Kyrie Eleison becomes this: (Celebrant): Loving Lady, have mercy; (People): Mother Jesus, have mercy;
(Celebrant) Loving Lady, have mercy" - thereby giving Jesus both a sex change and children.

The prayers of the people - addressed to "Mother" - include the request that "every member of the Church may be your
handmaiden" - thereby praying that all men in the church get a sex change.

The prayer of confession is addressed to "Most Merciful Lady."

The Great Thanksgiving begins, "May the Holy Mother be with you," and continues: "It is truly right, Mother, to give you thanks;
for you alone are the I AM, living and true, dwelling in light inaccessible from before time and forever," and adds: "Blessed is
she who comes in the name of Love."

With the prayer "Mother, you loved the world so much that you sent your only Son to be our Savior. Incarnate by the Holy
Spirit, born of the Virgin Mary," the consecration prayer claims that Jesus has two mommies - and no Father.

Immediately after the consecration of the bread and the wine, the celebrant says, "Mother, we now celebrate this memorial of
your redemption." (A Freudian slip, perhaps?)

Oddly enough, the Lord's Prayer is unchanged - so this is the only spot in the service which addresses God as "Father."

The "Mass" ends when the celebrant tells the congregation, "Let us go forth empowered by the Love of our Lady," and the
congregation replies, "Blessed be."

THE FEMINIST "MORNING PRAYER" service is similar in spirit. After the confession of sin (again addressed to the "Most
Merciful Lady"), the celebrant says, "Nurturing Mother, have mercy on us; forgive us all our sins. Through your beautiful Son,
Jesus Christ, strengthen us in all goodness, and by the power of the Holy Spirit sustain our eternal life."

Before the psalms, the celebrant says, "The mercy of our Lady is everlasting: come let us adore her." After the Psalm readings,
the celebrant sings a new age Gloria Non Patri: "Glory to the Mother, and to her Son, and to the Holy Spirit: as it was in
the beginning, is now, and will be forever."

In this service, too, the Lord's Prayer was unmolested - but the celebrant precedes it with "May our Holy Lady be with
you...Let us pray the words of her beautiful Son, Jesus Christ."

The prayers of the people include "Keep your example of Motherhood ever before us; Let us see in all our children a
sacred trust from you" - an invocation that seems out of place here, since the Women's Ministries site lists the pro-abortion
Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice among "social justice" groups.

The General Thanksgiving at the end of the service starts, "Most merciful Mother, we your handmaidens give you thanks for
your great love for us and for all you have made." The service ends when the celebrant says, "Let us give thanks to our Lady;"
the congregation replies, "Blessed be."

AS EARLIER NOTED, this all began with Ms. Fox's first experience with walking the labyrinth at the 1996 Sacred Circles
conference at Washington National Cathedral. That day, "during a guided meditation led by Dr. Sarah Fahy, I had met the wise woman
who had told me, `Women are beautiful. You are beautiful,'" Fox wrote. "Immediately after I...walked one of the labyrinths set up
in the nave. To my surprise, as I entered the path I dissolved into tears. Questions welled up inside of me. Why had no one ever
told me I was beautiful? Why did I need to be told that women were beautiful? I sobbed my way into the center, where I sat
until I was once again composed. As I began my walk out, the Eucharist was being celebrated at the high altar. I decided I
would silently say these comforting, familiar words as I walked...But on this day, to my horror, these words I loved
turned to dust and ashes in my mouth. All I could hear was `He, Him, Lord, Son, Father'...I had heard the misogyny in the
liturgy, and there was no going back."

Fox continued, "I realized that I did not see my mother, my two daughters, or myself as made in the image of God. When I
looked at the liturgy I discovered there are 195 male nouns and pronouns in Rite I and 145 in Rite II. In both cases, there is
one reference to a woman - the Virgin Mary in the Creed. If our liturgy is our story, the telling of the life, death and
resurrection of Jesus Christ, where are the voices of the women that Jesus loved, respected, and held dear? Where is an
understanding of the holiness of being a daughter, wife, or mother? Wondering what it would be like to have a service to the
Divine Feminine, I used Rite II, Prayer D [from the 1979 Prayer Book] as a starting point and wrote such a Eucharist in 2001.

"If one feels that reading this service is blasphemous, I can only say that writing it felt even more so. Yet I felt called to
continue, for what else would allow us to see the narrowness of our current liturgy?...My hope is that this Eucharist will begin
a dialogue about the ways in which language affects the quality of our worship, our feelings towards God, and our sense of being
created in God's image."

As earlier indicated, this was not the first foray into the bizarre for TEC's Office of Women's Ministries. In 2004, there
was an outcry over two other offerings on OWM's section of the official church website: "A Women's Eucharist: A Celebration of
the Divine Feminine" and a "Liturgy for Divorce." The Women's Eucharist made no mention of Christ, nor of his Body and Blood,
but gave thanks to "Mother God" for things like menstrual blood and breasts.

It emerged that the Women's Eucharist had been on a Druid website since 1998. What's more, it had been penned by "Glispa,"
who turned out to be part of a husband/wife Episcopal clergy couple who up until a short time earlier had also been involved
with and promoting modern-day Druidism, including nude mating rituals and invocation of the "Horned God." Once exposed,
Pennsylvania clergy Glyn Ruppe-Melnyck and her husband, W. William Melnyck, repented of their Druidry; Mr. Melnyk lost his
parochial job over the issue but Mrs. Melnyk kept hers.

The two offending services, which were removed from the OWM website in the 2004 controversy, were part of OWM's "Women's
Liturgy Project" to collect worship resources written by women for women - an initiative that, given the latest from the OWM, is
evidently ongoing.

*Sources included: Sandra Thomas Fox, "Reflection on the Holy Eucharist," Women's Ministries,
http://www.ecusa.anglican.org/41685_60499_ENG_HTM.htm; Women's Ministries, "Liturgies Using Feminine Images,"
http://www.ecusa.anglican.org/41685_60497_ENG_HTM.htm, a page that links to texts for the two liturgies; Women's
Ministries, http://www.ecusa.anglican.org/41685_31001_ENG_HTM.htm, a blurb for the Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice.



This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?





Weblog Commenting by HaloScan.com

<< # St. Blog's Parish ? >>